SXSW 2010

The Whigs

The Whigs at Palm Door, March 18, 2010. Photo by Chris Barth.

Palm Door
Austin, TX

Thursday, March 18, 2010

Words by Chris Barth
Photos by Chris Barth

Published on melophobe April 9, 2010.

See all 11 photos

What else we were talking about that week

The Whigs are one of those bands that have just kind of been hanging around the collective consciousness for some time now. They found themselves the focus of a lot of buzz when they were named a band to watch by Rolling Stone in 2006, but they've never really managed to parlay that potential into real success. Their live show is indicative of this juxtaposition; a combination of garage rock and psychedelic exploration, their set bore witness to the struggle of talented musicians hindered by mediocre songwriting. The Whigs' recorded material does a poor job of capturing their raw power - this trio really can shred when they let it all hang out. "Kill Me Carolyne" was a memorable highlight in concert, but on record it falls flat - a middling rock song. At their best, The Whigs recalled The Black Keys or The White Stripes. At weaker points, though, they resembled a watered down version of those bands - perhaps a telling sign.

Photos by Chris Barth

More at Palm Door

Related reviews